definearth

Is it me, or do dinner parties spark the best conversations? The last dinner party I attended birthed a discussion surrounding animal sentience. Three Bags Full is an internationally best selling novel about a flock of sheep who are driven to solve their shepherd’s murder. It was originally written in German by Leonie Swann, a writer with degrees in philosophy, psychology, and communication. No doubt her education background contributed to the ever-present theme of animal sentience in this peculiar, witty mystery.

Studies have shown that animals have stress responses, personality traits, and can obtain a certain IQ level. However, the real difficulty of deciding whether or not animals are sentient lies in the definition. What constitutes sentience? If it’s emotion, then our pets qualify. If it’s a stress response, then a meager shrimp is sentient. If the deciding factor is the knowledge of a difference between right and wrong then criminals aren’t sentient…And if it’s the awareness of our own mortality, then humans are sentient, but we ignore the possibility that animals have thoughts we can’t study in terms of heart rates and vocalizations.

“…Personality is discernible even in fish, which are often seen as being singularly lacking in emotional range. Scientists have found that the personality type of a fish may affect its likelihood of having certain parasites, or its ability to move past a barrier in a stream when on migration.” – Jan Hoole on The Conversation

In Three Bags Full, sheep are intelligent in their own way. Sure, they get distracted from solving the case on a regular basis. They worry about wolves even though they’ve only ever seen ghosts. They practice looking normal and focusing so they don’t attract too much human attention. But they understand ~roughly~ how humans work. Sheep have their own values, too. A strong sense of smell is well respected in the community, as is a good memory and thick wool. By the way: A shepherd should always wear his flock’s wool as to not offend them.

“Some people talk to animals. Not many listen though. That’s the problem.” – A.A. Milne, Winnie The Pooh

I won’t spoil the end of the story for you, but it has to do with this quote from Winnie The Pooh. The sheep were smarter than people expected. Yes, I know the novel is fictional. But it brings up a fun topic. Are sheep sentient?